Where were you when the November 29th issue of the New York Post dropped in 2006? I was likely sitting in my room, cutting up tabloid magazines my mom bought me while in line at the grocery store. I had a composition notebook dedicated to each celebrity I liked and I would cut out every photo of them and glue them in their designated notebook. Listen, I had social anxiety and needed my weird, meaningless little hobbies to get me through. Give me a break!
The now-infamous New York Post issue featured a paparazzi photo of Britney Spears, Lindsay Lohan, and Paris Hilton with the headline “Bimbo summit” splashed on the front page. Of course, calling it the Bimbo Summit is fucking hilarious, but at the same time, spurring national speculation and public scorn on three young women is very much Not Chill. Two things can be true at once.
In her book, Paris: The Memoir, Hilton describes the moment: “Lindsay got in the car, which was kind of awkward because I was driving a Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren that had only two seats. She got in, and Britney kind of wedged up on the middle thing where, ideally, you would put your purse. On a video that captured this moment, there’s a collective gasp, and then one of the paps says, ‘Oh, this is gonna be classic!’”
And that pap was right! The Post’s cover photo began racking up headlines, causing even more rumors to swirl about the three and their alleged on-and-off-again feuds. Just as Paris says in her book, someone bought a house with those pictures.
“I tried to stay out of the alleged “feuds” the tabloids were always whipping up. They constantly printed complete BS about my “bitter feud” with a friend I had no issue with or my “catfight” with some stranger I stood three feet from on a red carpet.”
While Paris claims these feuds were “BS” in her book, I think the truth likely lies somewhere in the middle. Even on her podcast, she kind of backtracks this by saying: “[Spears and I] were walking to the car and all of a sudden got swarmed by tons of paparazzi. Just as we were walking to the car, that’s when Lindsay came up. It was kind of awkward because we were having some drama.”
Given all the bad press at the time, and given that Lindsay was leaving the party with publicist Elliot Mintz, it’s not too far-fetched to assume that Elliot saw an opportunity to smooth things over publicly after Lindsay called Paris a c*nt on camera. Either way, whether there was a real feud or a PR-manufactured one, it almost doesn’t matter because the public didn’t need, nor care about, the truth.
Take Her to The She-otine!
Before paparazzi up-skirts, toxic tabloids, and hell, even photography itself, there was Queen Marie Antoinette. Like many young women before her, and like many after, Marie Antoinette unfairly became an entire country’s punching bag long before she ever lost her head. A teenager who was shipped off to a foreign court before she barely hit puberty quickly became a symbol for France’s wealth gap. (Hey, if you became queen of an entire country when you were a teenager, I’d dare you to not spend your country’s gold on pugs and macarons!) She was a favorite subject of the local political pamphlets, known as libelles. They accused her of every imaginable depravity — having orgies in the palace (cool), having a lesbian affair with the Princesse de Lamballe (very cool), committing incest with her own son (ew), and being a foreign agent (eh). Much like the social media pile-ons of today, a fictional monstrous version of Marie was quickly erected for public consumption.
After they attempted to flee Paris during the early years of the revolution, King Louis XVI and Queen Marie Antoinette both became frequent targets of French caricature artists. The way they were strong-holding their royalism while their people were struggling quickly turned public opinion against them, to say the least. In the image below, an anonymous artist portrays the royal couple as a two-headed creature. The king is given the body of a pig and the horns of a cuckold, no doubt a reference to his wife’s rumored affairs. The queen sports the body of a hyena wearing a fancy headdress of snakes and ostrich feathers, a pun on her Austrian heritage. But of all the rumors, none has stuck in the cultural zeitgeist quite like these four little words she never said. "Let them eat cake."
People may be shocked to discover that she wasn’t only misquoted, there is actually zero evidence that she ever said the phrase at all. The phrase can be traced back to Rousseau’s Confessions, written before Marie ever set foot in France, and is in reference to an unnamed “great princess.” The first time the quote was even connected to Marie was in 1843, fifty years after her execution. (It’s one thing for a rumor to spiral during your lifetime but for one to retroactively be attached to you then remembered for centuries as fact? Damn…) But as a writer, I must admit, it makes for a really good soundbite. Much like the tabloids of the early aughts, or the social media pile-ons of today, the formula has always been the same for tearing someone in the public down — make it anonymous, salacious, unverifiable, and designed to be consumed rather than believed. Again, the truth was never the goal.
Despite the countless examples of how fame is a monstrous burden, there is still no shortage of folks willing to claw their way to the top. We’ve seen the extremes one is willing to go through to be seen, adored, and immortalized. They sacrifice their privacy, their communities, and in many ways, their dignity to promote themselves and their work. Are they not aware that underneath the glittering facade of fame is a dark underbelly that needs to be fed?
We have to assume that nobody chases fame believing that they will end up bald and smashing a car window with an umbrella. We can watch it happen to hundreds of others and still believe, “not me, though.” That’s that indomitable human optimism! In her book The Age of Magical Overthinking, Amanda Montell describes what she calls “the halo effect,” an unconscious tendency to make positive assumptions about a person’s overall character based on our impressions of one single trait. Who among us has not felt like everyone around you is more successful based on your Instagram feed? We assume famous people must be happy and fulfilled because they are rich and successful, which glosses over a lot of the sacrifices they had to make to get there. Despite a mountain of visible casualties, the myth of fame is a lot stronger than the evidence against it.
“Anyone who is someone first started out as a delusional dreamer.”
But say what you will about fame, it does deliver on the promises it makes. It can bring you money, validation, and an escape from the ordinary. So even when one is aware that the burden is real, they also know the payoff is as well. Of course, not everyone in the spotlight chooses this life. Some were pushed into it. I mean, it’s not like Marie Antoinette was sending out self-tapes to audition for the role of Queen of France. There are many ways one can have fame thrust upon them — through birth, marriage, one viral video. But it hardly matters how you got there, the monster still needs to eat.
It’s probably worth mentioning that I will be referencing mostly (eh, all) women in this post. That’s not to say that men don’t also experience the real cost of fame, but there is an inflation that comes with being a woman in the spotlight. While male celebrities can certainly make tabloid headlines, it tends to skew toward a scandal or an actual wrongdoing of theirs. As opposed to women who could trend for simply existing; for her appearance, her body, her sexuality and the level at which she expresses it, her “likability,” her decisions on motherhood, how she is aging, etc… you get it.
Birth of a Baddie
There is an enigmatic “it factor” to the baddie It girl, an intangible quality that allows her to captivate attention and admiration with the flick of her glossy pony. The It girl is a beautiful contradiction. She is both aspirational and elusive; both known and unknown. She commands attention, yet remains mysterious. It’s up for debate whether one gets to choose their own path to baddie-dom, or if they are assigned at birth. Either way, one thing is certain, and that’s the level of audacity one must possess to become an It girl. In Julia Fox’s book, Down the Drain, she says, “Because the truth is, anyone who is someone first started as a delusional dreamer.” You can’t keep a true baddie down! If it could be anyone, why not her?
But one can’t raise their star on audacity alone. Self-belief only gets you into the room. It’s the audience that decides whether you’re allowed to stay, and what you’re allowed to become once you’re there. She can build the persona, but she doesn’t get to build the audience’s appetite for it. There is a psychological cost that comes with being a muse rather than a person. Sometimes the price of being seen is losing sight of yourself. The baddie’s journey is one of constant reinvention, straddling the line between self-creation and self-preservation. Is it even possible to be both aspirational and elusive? And can you do it without owning a statement coat?
While the line can be thin, there is a distinction between the It Girl and the Celebrity. Where the It girl gives an air of effortlessness, the Celebrity actually wants it, and she’s not afraid to show it. For example, despite all of her influence, Taylor Swift is not an It girl. She is a capital-C Celebrity. Relatability and It girl status are fundamentally incompatible. It girls run on scarcity, something the average person cannot have, but their allure is so strong that their fans will settle for crumbs. (For example, I could never be as cool as the Olsen twins, but I can buy the $45 shoes Mary-Kate wore in this one picture.) Taylor’s model runs on the complete opposite of the It girl. She relies on the parasocial intimacy she creates with her fans to create mass appeal and accessibility. She lets her fans into her world with Easter eggs, annotations, and explanations of her songs. Hey, admittedly it has made her one of the biggest stars alive, but that doesn’t make her an It girl.