Since the third season of House of the Dragon came to a close on Sunday, I’m not quite ready to leave Westeros yet. This always happens to me when these shows end, and that’s usually when I find myself doing a Game of Thrones rewatch or, in this case, a reread of A Song of Ice and Fire. Despite all the valid criticism this series faces, at the end of the day, I love this world, and I’ll pretty much eat whatever they throw into my HBO-branded trough!
Last year I reread the Harry Potter series for the first time in over a decade and (nerd alert) I had a blast annotating them. Since then, I have been itching to do the same with this series. Granted, this is a much bigger project to take on than a series written for kids, which is probably why it’s taken me a year to actually to do it. This will be my third time reading the series — once while waiting impatiently in between seasons of the show, another during the pandemic, and now, a deep-dive analysis. 🧐
For the fun of it, I’ve decided I’ll do a little annotation read-along as I go! I’ve never done this before, but I’m hoping these posts will be less of a plot recap and more of an analysis of George R.R. Martin as a writer, and why this series in particular has grabbed hold of millions of people.
I’ve talked before about my annotation strategy in general, and my favorite part is trying to determine what themes and devices I’ll be on the lookout for before I even start reading. I usually like to cap it somewhere around six themes. Otherwise, you’re getting too granular and can quickly start losing the plot. (Literally.) But the great thing about annotating is that the options are virtually endless, and even on future rereads, there’s always an opportunity to track something new! Here is what I’ve decided to track this round:
- With several point-of-view characters, everyone is operating on incomplete or dead-wrong information, and as the reader we’re often the only ones who hold the full picture. Especially during a reread, we know a lot more than these characters… and it’s going to get rough. This is where I’ll be tracking dramatic irony and character biases. I anticipate I’ll be reaching for these orange tabs a lot…
- George is a great storyteller and often plants things early on just to watch them detonate several books later. The beauty of a reread is that you can pick up on these subtle little drops in the moment. This is where my foreshadowing tabs will come in handy. This world is also big on prophecies, so I’ll be tracking those with the same blue tabs also.
- They don’t call it the Game of Thrones for nothing, folks! The themes of power and politics run deep in this series. I’ll be using yellow tabs to track the mechanics of who holds the power in this world and what it has cost them to get it (and keep it).
- Saint or sinner, no one in this world gets off scot-free. One of my favorite things about this series is how George doesn’t write his characters as purely good or purely bad. Just like in real life, these characters are often morally complex, and unfortunately, doing the right thing and doing the smart thing are not always the same thing. I’ll be using purple tabs to track themes of honor versus pragmatism.
- One thing about this series: people gonna die! I’ll probably have to stock up on more pink tabs because I’ll be using those to track character deaths, violence and war.
- I've always been impressed by fantasy authors who can build such vivid worlds from scratch. Complete with their own language, customs, stereotypes, history, lore, etc! George’s worldbuilding is one of the reasons people resonate with this universe so hard. I’ll be tracking Westerosi history and lore with green tabs.
- Again, there are a lot of characters in this series, and each has their own characteristics and story arcs. I’ll be using brown tabs to track character development throughout the entire series. This outta be good…
I’ll be covering roughly 3-5 chapters per post, which means… this will take awhile. Five main books, and if I’m feeling up to it, I’m also hoping to read Fire & Blood and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms for the first time afterwards. That’s seven dense, historical text-ass doorstoppers. And to be honest, I’m probably not committing the next, like, ten months to reading only seven books. (I have a reading goal to hold myself accountable to!) So, this is going to be a slow burn. (Bring snacks!)
Spoiler alert: I’m not doing spoiler alerts. I cannot consider those who haven’t read and/or seen the show as I write these, soooo make sure you don’t care about that moving forward from here!
Prologue
How do you begin a series with a promised seven books, spanning across decades, with countless character arcs and more twists than a damn rollercoaster? George had one shot to convince fantasy readers in 1996 that this series was worth the commitment. (And a commitment it surely has been. For those who don’t know, we still haven’t gotten the last two books of the series. (And we never will.)) Some may find it odd that he chose to shoot his shot with three minor characters who die before we get two pages into chapter one, but he had his reasons.
We begin in medias res, which is just a fancy way to say “in the middle of things.” It is a common literary device that throws the reader right into the action. It may leave us momentarily disoriented — where are we, who are these people, what are they doing, and what the hell is a wildling? — but the tradeoff is instant momentum. This is fantasy, which means we’re about to learn a bunch of made-up names from a bunch of made-up places. (You saw the giant map in the beginning, right?) So it’s this exact curiosity that, when executed correctly, makes aaaaall of the exposition we’re about to read feel earned rather than seem like a boring info dump. Once you have the reader hooked on the wildling threat, they’ll happily sit through paragraphs describing the hierarchy of the Night’s Watch because now that information actually matters to them.
In this case, the in medias res is working as a pretty great hook here because we’re opening on a bunch of characters who are really, really wrong about some pretty crucial plot points. (“Dead is dead”… you wish, buddy.) These first few lines are all about whether or not something is dead, and even those reading for the first time can assume an author wouldn’t dedicate the whole first paragraph of their novel to something so irrelevant. George is letting us know right off the bat, hey, never trust a character who is confident he is completely right.
The chapter continues with the three rangers making their way back to the Wall after fighting wildlings. They are led by a confident Ser Waymar Royce, the youngest son of a house with too many heirs. As readers, we are given every reason to distrust Waymar’s confidence. At eighteen, he’s only been on the Night’s Watch for a few months, and compared to Gared, who at the age of fifty has been there for forty years, we have to wonder what makes him so qualified to lead. Well, to the detriment of many, in this world, it’s your name and status that give you authority, not your experience. We will see this come to bite many characters in the ass. (In this series, it’s safe to assume that if a character is too cocky, they will surely be punished for it.)
At this point, we barely even know what the Night’s Watch is, and yet, we see that Royce was groomed for this position as a child. For men like him, highborn men too low on the totem pole to inherit anything, the Night’s Watch is a genuine honor. And yet, barely two paragraphs later, we learn that Will was given a very different choice: take “the black,” or lose a hand. Soooo, is it an honor or is it a punishment? We’ll soon find out that it’s a little of both…
George rarely tells us who a character is straight up. He’ll give us all the pieces — their clothes, their swords, their direwolves — and it’s up to us to do the math ourselves. He loves to describe his characters through objects, which is one of my favorite things about his writing! Like in this passage describing Gared’s sword. We don’t know much about his backstory, but we can assume he probably didn’t arrive at the Night’s Watch forty years ago with moleskin gloves and a wool coat like Royce did.
The prologue ends with a supernatural cliffhanger, but the more important theme here is how honor and dignity play a role in this world. As Waymar Royce comes face to face with a thing he clearly doesn’t stand a chance against, George doesn’t let him pretend to be anything other than frightened. Despite all of the undercutting this chapter does to his character, we gotta hand it to Waymar because he faces his death head-on. As Will so poetically puts it after watching him die, “he was a boy no longer, but a man of the Night’s Watch.” Waymar was genuinely very brave in his final moments, but he is also genuinely very dead. This is a pattern we will become all too familiar with. This world takes honor deadly seriously…
It’s no secret that George was generally inspired by J.R.R. Tolkien (I mean, right down to the R.R.), whose characters in The Lord of the Rings were almost always rewarded for their honor and bravery. But right in the prologue, George lets us know that this is not that kind of story. Much like in real life, honor is costly and rarely protects you. But while honor may be deadly in this world, it’s also one of the only things that matter. We’ll soon find that cowardice and broken oaths are unforgivable because they are a threat to the only thing that is keeping this system from falling apart. All one has is their word, and as Ned puts it in the next chapter, “the deserter knows his life is forfeit if he is taken, and he will not flinch at any crime no matter how vile.”
In the show, they call them White Walkers, not The Others, maybe to eliminate any confusion on who they mean by “others.” Also, the group finds the bodies of the Wildlings they presumed dead arranged in a very disturbing pattern. In one of the episode commentaries, they say this was to signal to the audience that whatever is happening is an intelligent force, not wild animals or some kind of natural disaster.
CHAPTER ONE | BRAN
We jump to Winterfell, where seven-year-old Bran is riding to witness a man being beheaded. (We’ve all been there!) In the prologue, Gared explains to Royce how “nothing burns like the cold,” pulling back his hood to show him where he’s been affected by frostbite. “Two ears, three toes, and the little finger off my left hand.” So it comes as quite a shock when, just three pages later, we learn that it’s Gared’s beheading Bran is about to witness. It’s a very clever way of letting the reader in on it before the characters catch up! (Also, just a fun little note that someone else picked up on: in the prologue, Gared describes how peaceful it is to die by freezing, and the sword that decapitates him is named “Ice.”)
The show adds a scene before the beheading with Bran practicing shooting arrows with the family around. This is likely to establish the family dynamic earlier so that the show audience knows who to root for. It is also Will who gets beheaded as a deserter, not Gared.
With so many characters and so little time, George needs to instill character traits immediately to help us keep them all straight. In the previous chapter, Royce is the cocky young hotshot, Gared is the jaded old man, and Will is practical and cautious. In Bran’s chapter, we see he’s a young boy trying to appear grown. Jon is protective and steady beyond his years, while Robb reads as composed and dutiful.
I think we can all agree that laughing at a rolling decapitated head is an unlikable trait — Theon Greyjoy is immediately presented to us as obnoxious and lacking empathy. (As if that’s not bad enough, he was all too ready to kill puppies!!) But that’s exactly what makes him a great character foil for Jon. It’s Theon’s unlikability that brings Jon’s likability into sharper focus. In this chapter alone, we see them having opposite reactions a couple of times — once when Theon laughs at the beheading and later when Jon convinces Ned to let them keep the direwolves instead of letting Theon kill them. George doesn’t outright tell us that Jon is our hero, but we immediately like the guy because he doesn’t derive joy from a beheading and he’s down to save a litter of puppies. (The bar is on the ground.)
We also get Ned’s iconic line in this chapter: “That is the only time a man can be brave”? Come on! What a banger! The first thing we learn about Ned is that he has a code. He doesn’t just kill this man begrudgingly because he’s the lord, but rather because of his own personal philosophy: A ruler who delegates the killing “soon forgets what death is.” (Damn, he’s wise as hell.) Ned values honor and accountability, and he clearly refuses to let his own power make him sit too comfortably. And because Ned is telling all of this to his seven-year-old son unprompted, we can tell that he is not saying this as performance.
We also get a bit of Stark worldbuilding here as we learn that they are “the blood of the First Men,” and have an older way of doing things than what the previous rulers have practiced. This lets us know that honor is not a character trait specific to Ned, but that it is possibly inherited throughout the Stark family. The main thing we need to take away from this is that this is a man whose principles are his entire identity — and yet, we get some conflicting information about Ned’s honor because Jon is his bastard son. Not so honorable when it comes to your WIFE, huh?? Seems a little out of character for him. I wonder… if something… will be revealed… about Jon’s parentage… hm…
Speaking of Jon, on the way back to the castle he and Robb find a litter of orphaned direwolf pups. It is a shock, not only because of the wolf’s size, but because direwolves have not been seen on this side of the Wall for centuries. (Maybe a small nod from George telling us that the Wall might not be keeping things out the way it used to?) And because this one has been found dead, it brings on a sort of dread to the adults in the group. Ned tries to rationalize it, but even he couldn’t help but feel uneasy when they discover the antler in its throat.
Despite Robb and Bran’s objections, Ned’s men want no part of this whole ‘dead direwolf puppies’ thing and Theon is all too happy to put them out of their misery. Luckily, Jon steps in to point out that there are five direwolf pups, one for each of the Stark children. Of course, this math only checks out because Jon has excluded himself. While we have no reason to believe that Jon has been treated as anything other than a son, excluding himself unprompted here shows that he is still aware of his place. Jon saying, “I am no Stark,” is one of the best examples of retrospective dramatic irony in the series. I know I said I wasn’t going to do spoiler alerts, but spoiler alert: Not only is Jon not a bastard, but he is actually the trueborn son of the late Lyanna Stark and a Rhaegar Targaryen. (If I remember correctly, this is not directly stated in the books? However, I’m pretty sure it’s confirmed true.)
Typically when we track these character biases, it’s the character being wrong about other people. This is Jon being fundamentally wrong about himself. Ned’s silence afterward reads completely different on reread because Ned knows the truth and he is protecting him. From a storytelling perspective, George is not just playing around with typical foreshadowing here. He is planting a false belief of a character’s identity, to which he will hold on to for years, and letting us hold that same belief right along with him. But even as written, this scene is still just a sad moment where we witness how Jon truly sees himself — a shameful outsider.
As mentioned in the prologue with Gared’s sword, George again gives us some great character descriptions through other objects. Jon finds a sixth pup off in the distance. He is different than the rest, but unlike the others, he has his eyes open. It makes sense why Jon would feel a connection to this weird little outsider. As the bastard son, Jon has likely had to observe a lot from the sidelines, giving him a lot of opportunity to see what others cannot. But is seeing before everyone else all it’s cracked up to be? There can be plenty of vulnerability in gaining knowledge before you are ready. I guess we’ll find out…
Fun fact: George allegedly wrote this direwolf scene first!
CHAPTER TWO | CATELYN
The show adds a quick scene introducing Cersei and Jamie Lannister before jumping back to Winterfell. My guess is so there is a bigger payoff later when we find out they are boinking each other and that the kids are… actually… his.
While her chapter is only a mere five pages, Catelyn’s perspective hands us a lot of worldbuilding lore that would have taken us, like, twenty chapters to piece together ourselves. Despite being married to a Stark for years, Catelyn still feels like a foreigner — and there’s no better way to learn the little quirks of something than by being on the outside of it. She has genuine reason to notice all of the little differences between the Starks and the rest of Westeros, so it doesn’t feel like overt exposition.
Catelyn explains how different these Northerners are compared to the rest of Westeros, especially when it comes to religion. Catelyn was raised in the Faith of the Seven — priests, churches, gods with names and faces — while the Starks, by contrast, hold to the old gods — nameless, faceless, and probably older than faith itself. The fact that Ned built her a small sept where she could pray to her own gods is a tiny detail that says a lot about their marriage. While arranged (she was originally meant to marry her brother before he died), they clearly have a deep respect for each other.
“The man died well, I’ll give him that,” Ned said.
Again, we pick up quickly how important honor, bravery, and masculinity are in this world. Even a toddler is expected to toughen up. This is a harsh world, kid! You can’t be scared of a wolf pup! It’s a little funny, but it really goes to show how children in this world have to grow up fast. We already got that sense with seven-year-old Bran going to a beheading and a fourteen-year-old Jon already understanding the dynamic of him being born a bastard. This isn’t so much a knock on Ned’s parenting, but rather proof that this world doesn’t coddle anyone, so you better get used to it sooner rather than later. (Also, our first winter is coming drop!)
Through this conversation with Ned, we also circle back on a contradiction we picked up on in the prologue. Is the Night’s Watch an honor or a punishment? While they need honorable men, the Wall is losing people left and right, and desperate times call for desperate measures!
A keen reader may have picked up on the subtle symbolism of a stag’s antler being the death of a direwolf in the last chapter, but in case anyone missed it, Catelyn lays it out for us again. We learned that the direwolf is the sigil for House Stark in the last chapter. I don’t believe we know it just yet, but the stag is the sigil for House Baratheon. You’re not gonna get a more obvious omen than this, folks!! George knows it. We know it. Hell, even Catelyn knows it! As a rereader, you know exactly what the Stark family is about to endure, so Ned’s joy in this moment about seeing his best mate will have you wanting to scream at the book. (“Don’t do it!!!”) Of course, George doesn’t editorialize any of this here. To foreshadow any of this now would read as pretty heavy-handed and rob first-timers of the shock of… well, you know. (🧔🏻🗡️💀)
And that’s a wrap for my first annotate-with-me post! We were handed a lot of information — a mysterious creature, a fight to the death, a beheading, and a really (really) bad omen. Not bad for just three chapters in!