← back to the archive

happily never after

why we crave doomed love

Two households, both alike in dignity,
In fair Verona, where we lay our scene,
From ancient grudge break to new mutiny,
Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean.
From forth the fatal loins of these two foes
A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their life;
Whose misadventured piteous overthrows
Do with their death bury their parents' strife.


Spoiler alert: they both die.

That’s pretty much how Shakespeare started his famous tragedy, Romeo and Juliet. Only fourteen lines in and the audience already knows what kind of story they’re about to witness. No plot twists. These star-crossed lovers don’t make it in the end. And yet, four hundred years later, we’re still referencing it, and more interestingly, we’re still crying in the end. It seems to go against everything we’ve been taught about storytelling, about how one must keep the audience hooked with suspense. But in a doomed romance, the tragedy isn’t the surprise waiting to happen. The story is exactly as advertised and we love it!

As it turns out, this isn’t just some one-off quirk. In 2011, researchers at UC San Diego tested whether knowing a story’s ending actually hurts the experience. They took the same short stories across several genres and compared two versions with their test subjects. Across the board, the spoiled versions came back rated equally as enjoyable, and in some cases, even more so! I suppose it’s like rereading your favorite book. If you’re not spending your energy on trying to figure out what will happen, you’re free to actually pay attention to how it happens.

romeo and juliet

In 1997, Titanic was predicted to be a monumental flop. Even director James Cameron thought he was “headed for disaster” at one point during filming. “We labored the last six months on Titanic in the absolute knowledge that the studio would lose $100 million. It was a certainty.” It’s crazy to think about this now, knowing that it would become the first film in history to make a billion dollars worldwide. It held the record for the highest-grossing film ever made for at least a decade! Nobody walked into a three-hour movie about the famous Titanic expecting it to still be afloat in the end. But they went back, repeatedly, paying full price to watch the same disaster happen again! Even if audiences know how the story ends, that doesn’t mean there can’t be some anticipation about how or when the “thing” happens. After all the anticipation is stripped away, every viewing (or reading) is the audience chasing a specific feeling.

Aristotle described it as catharsis, the idea that tragedy lets you experience real grief, real fear, but at a safe distance. It’s a similar theory to why we love to be scared. You get all of the emotional intensity with none of the consequences! Think of it as a controlled, renewable dose of feelings.

titanic

I believe there are four main categories of the doomed love trope:

First is the star-crossed lovers. You’ll often find the term “star-crossed” thrown around in the romance space, oftentimes misused to describe two lovers who are meant to be together when it actually means the opposite. The stars (destiny, the heavens, the gods, what have you) have ruled against them and have crossed out their plans to be together. One of the most beloved versions of this trope is the “falling above one’s station.” These stories are baked into our brains at an early age — Cinderella, Aladdin, basically the entire Hallmark catalog. It’s the simple idea that love can bound across class lines and conquer anything. It is one of the oldest wish-fulfillment fantasies we’ve got.

Those examples aren’t doomed love, of course, as they all have happy endings. After all, somebody has to keep these fantasies alive! The doomed love version takes that same setup and confirms what we secretly suspected all along: that love can’t really fix it all. It takes that happy ending and tosses it out the window. In Titanic, Jack is a poor artist with nothing but a sketchbook and a third-class ticket, while Rose is old money and already engaged to a man worth ten times as much as Jack. The iceberg gets top billing when it comes to “things keeping them apart,” but the real threat to Jack and Rose was always going to be that her family would rather her marry rich than be happy. The ship going down just beats them to it.

Most notably, one of the most famous examples of this is The Great Gatsby. But Jay Gatsby doesn’t accept his class divide in the same way Jack does. Instead, he tries to buy his way to the other side, building his own fortune for the sole purpose of becoming someone worthy of Daisy. But tragically, (spoiler alert) it wasn’t enough. Daisy stays with her husband Tom, who totally sucks but was already born into the “right” kind of family. No matter how many extravagant parties or fancy shirts Gatsby owns, he’ll never actually be “one of them.”

great gatsby

Another doomed love category is the folie à deux, French for the “madness of two.” The term was coined in 1877 by psychiatrists to describe a rare condition where one person’s delusion gets transferred onto someone else. (I would love a delusion transfusion.) Today, this is less classified as a single disorder and more as a symptom of several different underlying psychotic disorders.

Bonnie and Clyde are probably the most classic case, so much so that their names are basically shorthand for this trope. Bonnie Parker was nineteen when she met Clyde Barrow in 1930. She was already married, and in fact, never actually divorced. (Fun fact, she was buried still wearing her wedding band.) By 1932, Clyde was on a legendary bank-robbing crime spree that lasted twenty-one months and spanned across six states — and Bonnie was right by his side. A true ride or die! Images of two young and in-love punks robbing banks and sticking it to the man immediately resonated with the public. (It was the Depression era, so folks had plenty of reason to root against the banks.) But all good things come to an end, and the two were eventually ambushed by police on a rural road in Louisiana. The officers allegedly fired over 130 rounds, leaving them each with about 50-60 bullet wounds by the end.

Almost 100 years later, we still hold on to the mythology of Bonnie and Clyde. Despite their high body count and violent crimes, the posed photographs of these two performing “young outlaws in love” still scratch that doomed love itch.

bonnie and clyde

That leads us to our next category: toxic and/or co-dependent. Unlike star-crossed lovers, the threat is not external. There are no family feuds, class divides, or giant icebergs getting in the way of their love succeeding. Here, the doom comes from inside the relationship itself. Their love is not threatened by poison — their love is the poison. Sid and Nancy are a prime example of this trope, as their relationship ran on addiction and volatility. Their story ends about as badly as these stories could go: Nancy dead of a stab wound and Sid overdosing months later while out on bail for her murder.

Not to be the girl who cried misogyny, but what’s interesting is that in this case, Nancy is remembered as the corrupting influence that led to Sid’s decline. She is hailed as the crazy girlfriend who dragged the rising Sex Pistols star into a life of heroin and ruin. (As if he arrived at her doorstep as a clean-cut choir boy…) This may be true, or it may be embellished, but I happen to know that this isn’t an isolated case. Rock ‘n’ roll has a long-standing habit of finding a woman to blame for a man’s self-destruction. For decades, Yoko Ono has gotten the blame for breaking up The Beatles, as if four grown men weren’t capable of having a creative fallout all on their own. Courtney Love has spent over thirty years fielding conspiracy theories that she was somehow behind Kurt Cobain’s death, despite hardly any evidence to support it. When Mac Miller died of an accidental overdose in 2018, months after his relationship with Ariana Grande had ended, his fans blamed her, despite his substance abuse predating and outlasting their relationship. As Ariana said herself, “shaming/blaming women for a man’s inability to keep his shit together is a very major problem.”

sid and nancy

Lastly, and possibly the most heartbreaking of all the doomed love categories, we have those doomed by prohibition. In Brokeback Mountain, the only thing standing between Ennis and Jack is that their love story is set in 1963 Wyoming. There were societal expectations for these men, and none of them included falling in love with each other and boning on a hillside. Instead, they both married women and occasionally met up on “fishing trips.” When Jack pushes for an actual life together, Ennis refuses out of fear. It’s hard to blame him, especially after his father tells him a horrible story about what happens to men like them. Jack dies before the story can resolve itself, and the details surrounding his death are never confirmed. Ennis is left with only two shirts, one tucked inside the other, and the memory of the mountain where they met. (My eyes are watering thinking about it. Fuck.)

So, why do we love doomed love so much? It could be because watching two youngsters throw caution to the wind and risk it all resembles an idealized romance that you just can’t get in the real world. (Well, I suppose you can, but not in a way any reasonably sane person would want.) We enjoy watching love triumph over every obstacle in its path, whether it be timing, class, addiction, or the law. It sends a message that love’s transformative power is still worth pursuing, even if it ends in tragedy. It’s a beautiful message. Naive, but beautiful.

brokeback mountain

There are a few other reasons that keep us coming back to this heartbreak:

  1. It’s intense. There is a magnetic pull to the type of love that has an expiration date. Every little moment, every small gesture feels heavier when we know what the outcome will be. A doomed romance doesn’t have the luxury of a slow, boring scene because everything is on borrowed time, even if the characters don’t know it yet.
  2. It’s authentic. We all want a happy ending, but some pairings could never survive reality. The addiction is too deep, the delusion is too far gone, the power dynamics are much too skewed. For the intensity of a doomed romance to work, the stakes have to feel real, and for many of these stories, that means the ending has to feel real too. A happy ending for Sid and Nancy, or Bonnie and Clyde, would feel inauthentic.
  3. It’s controlled catharsis. As previously mentioned, a doomed romance is not selling suspense. It's selling you a feeling. It allows you to access grief and heartbreak, but with the luxury of getting to sleep easily knowing none of that happened to you.

At the heart of all doomed love stories is a universal human longing for the unattainable. We love the idea of love against all odds, defying every obstacle that comes its way. But the tragic end mirrors the bittersweet nature of life itself. Joy and pain are often two sides of the same coin, and these stories allow us to live vicariously through the highs of passion and the heart-wrenching pains of loss.

thanks for reading, dolls! and if you find any typos they were a creative choice.

← back to the archive